FinCEN's $50 Billion Problem: Why Financial Crime Compliance Is Failing America

The numbers paint a disturbing picture. Financial criminals launder over $50 billion annually through US financial institutions, yet only one in twenty victims reports these crimes. Behind this staggering figure lies a complex web of regulatory failures, technological gaps, and human vulnerabilities that threaten the integrity of America's financial system.

From The Hill To The Trenches 

From The Hill To The Trenches: The Search for Justice takes listeners inside the world of financial crime compliance through conversations with industry experts, former law enforcement officials, and regulatory insiders. Hosted by Dorothy Hill, a former Goldman Sachs associate with extensive experience across five countries, including Germany and Japan, the podcast explores the intersection of money, power, and accountability in global financial systems.

Hill brings unique insight to complex financial crime topics, having trained in compliance by former FBI agents and advised both global banks and government agencies. Her international background provides perspective on how money moves through legitimate channels and shadowy networks worldwide.

In this episode, Hill interviews Brett Erickson, a financial crime strategist and sanctions governance advisor whose expertise sits at the intersection of compliance, geopolitics, and institutional risk. Erickson serves on advisory boards at Loyola University Chicago School of Law, DePaul University College of Business, and Seton Hall University's School of Diplomacy and International Relations.

With over 15 certifications including CAMS, CAMS-RM, CGSS, and CFE designations, Erickson has published analysis in major outlets including Newsweek, The Hill, American Banker, and ACAMS Today. His work focuses on identifying overlooked vulnerabilities in institutional governance and regulatory arbitrage across financial and non-financial institutions.

The SAR System Under Siege  

The Financial Crimes Enforcement Network (FinCEN) operates one of the world's most extensive financial surveillance systems. Banks, credit unions, and even casinos file suspicious activity reports (SARs) that feed directly into 350+ law enforcement agencies nationwide. These reports serve as the foundation for major financial crime investigations, helping authorities piece together fragmented criminal networks operating across multiple institutions.

However, this critical infrastructure faces a persistent and growing threat from within. Foreign adversaries and criminal organizations regularly attempt to compromise FinCEN employees, often succeeding with surprisingly modest financial incentives. Intelligence sources reveal that federal employees have been recruited for as little as $10,000 to $20,000 – a fraction of what many assume would be required to breach such sensitive systems.

The vulnerability stems from a fundamental misunderstanding of criminal economics. While potential recruits imagine they would need millions to justify risking their careers and freedom, adversaries understand that financial pressure, personal circumstances, and incremental compromise can achieve the same result at a fraction of the cost.

Mexican Banks and the Fentanyl Pipeline  

In June 2024, FinCEN took unprecedented action against three Mexican financial institutions suspected of facilitating fentanyl-related money laundering. The enforcement order required all US financial entities – from major banks to small credit unions and casinos – to completely block payments to these designated institutions.

This represents a seismic shift in anti-money laundering enforcement strategy. Rather than pursuing individual bad actors after crimes occur, regulators now target entire institutional networks suspected of enabling criminal activity. The approach acknowledges that modern money laundering operates at an industrial scale, requiring institutional-level responses.

For affected US banks, compliance demands extensive operational changes. Institutions must implement both automated filtering systems and human oversight procedures to ensure no transactions slip through. Additionally, they face the daunting task of conducting look-back reviews covering three to four years of historical transactions to identify and report any previous dealings with sanctioned entities.

The stakes are enormous. Banks that fail to implement these controls risk severe penalties properly, regulatory censure, or even license revocation in extreme cases. The enforcement action signals that financial crime compliance has evolved beyond a regulatory checkbox into a national security imperative.

The Cryptocurrency Blind Spot  

While traditional banking faces increasing scrutiny, cryptocurrency presents an entirely different challenge. Many Southeast Asian countries have responded to crypto-related crime by banning digital currency use entirely. However, this approach creates a dangerous oversight gap – criminals continue operating in these jurisdictions without any government monitoring or intervention.

The situation is complicated by mixing services like Tornado Cash, which allow users to obscure transaction origins by pooling assets with other users. When funds are withdrawn from these pools, determining their original source becomes virtually impossible. These services represent a fundamental challenge to traditional "follow the money" investigative techniques.

Perhaps more concerning is the expertise gap within financial institutions themselves. Most anti-money laundering professionals lack meaningful cryptocurrency knowledge, creating dangerous blind spots as digital currency adoption accelerates. The pool of qualified compliance professionals becomes increasingly narrow when dealing with crypto-related threats, precisely when institutions need this expertise most.

Building Better Defenses  

The solution requires a multi-pronged approach combining technological advancement, regulatory coordination, and professional development. Financial institutions must invest in cryptocurrency compliance training while regulators develop frameworks that address digital currency risks without stifling legitimate innovation.

For compliance professionals, the message is clear: traditional anti-money laundering approaches are insufficient for modern threats. Success requires continuous education, cross-border cooperation, and the ability to adapt quickly to evolving criminal tactics.

The Association of Certified Anti-Money Laundering Specialists (ACAMS) and Association of Certified Fraud Examiners (ACFE) offer specialized certifications that provide standardized knowledge baselines. These credentials become increasingly valuable as employers seek verifiable expertise in an AI-driven world where anyone can claim knowledge without demonstrating competency.

The Path Forward  

Financial crime compliance has reached an inflection point. The traditional reactive approach – investigating crimes after they occur – proves inadequate against sophisticated, well-funded criminal networks operating at international scale. Success requires proactive strategies, advanced technology, and professionals equipped with diverse skill sets spanning traditional banking, digital currencies, and geopolitical risk assessment.

The cost of failure extends far beyond regulatory penalties. Financial crime undermines market stability, erodes institutional trust, and enables everything from drug trafficking to terrorism financing. As criminal organizations become more sophisticated, the financial services industry must respond with equal innovation and determination.

The battle for financial integrity will be won or lost in compliance departments across America. The professionals working in these roles today are not just processing reports and checking boxes – they are defending the foundation of the global financial system itself.

Listen to the complete conversation between Dorothy Hill and Brett Erickson on From the Hill to the Trenches: The Search for Justice to discover additional insights about SAR writing techniques, sanctions compliance strategies, and career advancement opportunities for aspiring financial crime professionals in today's evolving regulatory landscape.

Follow From the Hills to the Trenches: The Search for Justice:
Website: Hill2Trenches.com

Follow Dorothy Hill:

LinkedIn: @dorothy-hill

Follow Brett Erikson:

LinkedIn:   @brett-p-erickson